Skip to content
  • (413) 834-4284
  • [email protected]
  • 21 Grinnell St, Greenfield, Massachusetts
Search
Close
Sprawl-busters
  • Home
  • About
  • Resources
    • Links
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Home Towns, Not Home Depot
    • The Case Against Sprawl
  • Victories
  • Blog
    • Share Your Battle
  • Contact
Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Resources
    • Links
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Home Towns, Not Home Depot
    • The Case Against Sprawl
  • Victories
  • Blog
    • Share Your Battle
  • Contact
  • Uncategorized

Court Rules Against Citizens In Nine Year Wal-Mart Battle

  • Al Norman
  • September 15, 2016
  • No Comments

Sprawl-Busters has been writing about a Wal-Mart battle in Ceres, California since 2007. A hearty group of local residents has held off the world???s largest retailer for nine years, with a see-saw battle in and out of court for years. This week, a court decision went against the Citizens for Ceres, but Wal-Mart is not a done deal yet.

On September 12, 2016, five years after the project was approved by the city of Ceres, the Fifth District Court of Appeal in Fresno ruled against the Citizens for Ceres and said that the Mitchell Ranch Center Wal-Mart Environmental Impact Report (EIR) was adequate. The Appellate Court also held Wal-Mart is not barred from collecting costs incurred by the City’s law firm in preparing the administrative record.

If the Citizens do not seek review by the California Supreme Court, the case will be remanded for further proceedings in the Trial Court in Modesto, California, for Wal-Mart to argue that its claimed costs are reasonable.

The Fresno Court ultimately held that the EIR’s treatment of air quality, urban decay, and solid waste impacts was supported by “substantial evidence” ??? giving great deference to the City’s findings. The Judge did take issue with the EIR’s treatment (or lack thereof) of human health impacts resulting from air pollution in his concurring opinion, but ultimately concluded this was not sufficient to overturn the project approval. Noting this topic is currently under review in the Supreme Court, the Justice wrote, “If Citizens seeks review of the air quality issues in the present case, our Supreme Court might grant review and defer briefing pending a decision in Sierra Club due to the possibility that the issues presented for review in this case will be affected by the conclusions and analysis adopted in deciding Sierra Club.???

The Citizens for Ceres expressed its appreciation for all the individuals who have helped the group.??? Group leader Sherri Jacobson said: ???Our members who include residents, voters, business and home owners ??? have remained patient and united for over nine years. We are still trying to understand how the law allows developers to substantially influence (and even write) Environmental Impact Reports, responses to residents’ concerns regarding the environmental studies, and even City findings, when the public is lead to believe Cities address those issues independently. According to the record, Wal-Mart, through its lawyers, lobbyists, and consultants greatly influenced the environmental studies in this case and the City’s decision to approve the project.”

Jacobson continued, “Citizens for Ceres now has approximately 30 days to discuss this matter with all members, our public, and our attorney, and our group will soon decide if we are going to seek review in the Supreme Court. We look forward to moving forward as a group in Ceres, CA.”

In 2013, the same Appellate Court ruled in Citizens for Ceres??? favor and concluded Wal-Mart and the City had erred in withholding thousands of documents in the case. The City and Wal-Mart claimed they had “common interests” in approving the project and therefore their communications prior to the project approval were privileged. The Appellate Court strongly disagreed and concluded the city must remain neutral until the project is approved.

The issue of certifying the EIR first failed on a 2-1 vote, only to see Wal-Mart and the City Council reconvene several days later to re-vote, resulting in certifying the EIR and approving the project — with no substantive changes to the EIR from the prior denial.

To read more stories about this epic battle against sprawl, go to:

http://www.sprawl-busters.com/search.php?SRCHstory=Ceres

Sprawl-Busters has been writing about a Wal-Mart battle in Ceres, California since 2007. A hearty group of local residents has held off the world???s largest retailer for nine years, with a see-saw battle in and out of court for years. This week, a court decision went against the Citizens for Ceres, but Wal-Mart is not a done deal yet.

Like this article?

Share on facebook
Share on Facebook
Share on twitter
Share on Twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on Linkdin
Share on pinterest
Share on Pinterest
Al Norman

Al Norman

Al Norman first achieved national attention in October of 1993 when he successfully stopped Wal-Mart from locating in his hometown of Greenfield, Massachusetts. Almost 3 decades later they is still not Wal-Mart in Greenfield. Norman has appeared on 60 Minutes, was featured in three films, wrote 3 books about Wal-Mart, and gained widespread media attention from the Wall Street Journal to Fortune magazine. Al has traveled throughout the U.S., Barbados, Puerto Rico, Ireland, and Japan, helping dozens of local coalitions fight off unwanted sprawl development. 60 Minutes called Al “the guru of the anti-Wal-Mart movement.”

Leave a comment

Find Us

  • 21 Grinnell St, Greenfield, MA
  • (413) 834-4284
  • [email protected]

Helpful Links

  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
Menu
  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Recent Posts

CHRISTIAN SMALLS, FIRED AMZN WAREHOUSE WORKER, FILES RACE DISCRIMATION LAWSUIT. …

November 16, 2020

DUE TO THE SURGE IN CORONA CASES, WMT IS LIMITING SHOPPERS TO 5 PER 1,000 SF. A…

November 16, 2020

AMAZON RECENTLY ANNOUNCED FREE 1 HOUR GROCERY PICK UP FOR PRIME MEMBER ORDERS &g…

November 15, 2020

AFTER BEING REJECTED BY THE DEERFIELD, MA PLANNING BOARD, DOLLAR GENERAL APPEALS…

November 15, 2020

WILL TRUMP ALLOW ORACLE & WALMART TO INVEST IN TIK TOK? The deadline to ban …

November 14, 2020

AMAZON ACCUSED OF BREAKING ANTITRUST RULES IN EUROPE. “Data of 3rd-party sellers…

November 14, 2020

WALMART PET CARE NOW SELLING PET INSURANCE. My 3 year old mixed breed cat would …

November 13, 2020

WALMART’S GOING TO THE DOGS. 90 M OF ITS CUSTOMERS HAVE DOGS. You’d be Goofy not…

November 13, 2020

WALMART CASHIERS STILL LOOKING FOR A SEAT. They won a $65 M lawsuit in 2019, but…

November 12, 2020

4 DAYS BEFORE THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION,THE CO-FOUNDER OF HOME DEPOT SAID: “Pres…

November 12, 2020

Recent Tweets

Al Norman 12 hours ago

BUY AMERICAN, OR BYE, AMERICAN? Unions in New York State want WMT to pressure GE-SAVANT not to move its lightbulb plant from Ohio to China. The unions want WMT to live up to its “Made in America” rhetoric. https://t.co/i1BR1VHJSm

Read More
Al Norman 12 hours ago

ON JAN 28, A MAN USED CAMPING FUEL TO SET 4 FIRES IN A CO. WALMART. The same day a man used lighter fluid to start a fire in an Arizona Walmart that did $10 M damage. Bizarre crimes, every day at Walmart. https://t.co/k4cQX1bplu

Read More
Al Norman 1 day ago

INSTEAD OF HAVING PERSONAL SHOPPERS FILL YOUR WALMART ORDER INSIDE THE STORE, A “Little Fulfillment Center” will be built behind the store for pick up & delivery. This shifts more production costs to WMT—but they hope it will steal business from Amazon. https://t.co/ypVFBojcpn

Read More

Ⓒ 2020 - All Rights Are Reserved

Design and Development by Just Peachy Web Design

Download Our Free Guide

Download our Free Guide

Learn How To Stop Big Box Stores And Fulfillment Warehouses In Your Community

The strategies written here were produced by Sprawl-Busters in 2006 at the request of the United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW), mainly for citizen groups that were fighting Walmart. But the tips for fighting unwanted development apply to any project—whether its fighting Dollar General, an Amazon warehouse, or a Home Depot.

Big projects, or small, these BATTLEMART TIPS will help you better understand what you are up against, and how to win your battle.