Skip to content
  • (413) 834-4284
  • [email protected]
  • 21 Grinnell St, Greenfield, Massachusetts
Search
Close
Sprawl-busters
  • Home
  • About
  • Resources
    • Links
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Home Towns, Not Home Depot
    • The Case Against Sprawl
  • Victories
  • Blog
    • Share Your Battle
  • Contact
Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Resources
    • Links
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Home Towns, Not Home Depot
    • The Case Against Sprawl
  • Victories
  • Blog
    • Share Your Battle
  • Contact
  • Uncategorized

Dentist Sues Wal-Mart For Stealing His In-Store Clinic Idea

  • Al Norman
  • February 11, 2013
  • No Comments

Ask almost anyone who has sued Wal-Mart over the past half century, and they will tell you that getting justice out of the giant retailer is like pulling teeth. That may be a good sign for a California dentist who claims that Wal-Mart conspired with others to steal his concept for a dental clinic inside of big box stores.

Just before Christmas, Dr. Kianor Shah filed a lawsuit in Riverside County, California Superior Court, naming Wal-Mart Stores Inc. and Comfort Care Dental Management (CCDM), of Delaware, as defendants charged with counts of civil conspiracy, misappropriation of trade secrets, breach of contract and confidence, tortious interference with prospective economic advantage, and other “violation of laws, requirements, and regulations.”

According to Dr. Shah, in late 2008, he developed plans for opening low-cost, full service dental offices in big-box retailers like Wal-Mart. Dr. Shah presented the idea to Wal-Mart, which initially committed to trying Dr. Shah’s in-store clinics. But the retailer subsequently told Shah it had changed its mind, and had no interest in dental clinics.

But Dr. Shah claims that Wal-Mart then revealed his plans to Kent Reeves, former Wal-Mart Vice President of New Business Development, and Ken Antos, a restaurant business partner. In 2012, Wal-Mart opened a dental clinic inside its store in Moreno Valley, California, managed by Christopher Comfort of CCDM, Kent Reeves and Ken Antos. Shah says in his litigation that the Moreno Valley clinic was based almost entirely on his specifications, even down to the type of dental chairs used.

In one of the more bizarre twists in the story, in late 2011, Dr. Shah moved from Illinois to California. “Needing a job,” the lawsuit says, Dr. Shah responded to a Craiglist add placed by Comfort Care for a dentist for an in-store clinic at a Wal-Mart. In April of 2012, Shah was hired to work in the clinic that he had conceptualized. Dr.Shah writes that he “quickly realized” that Comfort’s dental office was “almost an exact replica” of the dental office that Shah had shown Wal-Mart almost three years earlier.

At the grand opening of the Wal-Mart dental clinic, Shah said it was “crystal clear” to him that the defendants had “stolen” his business model. When Wal-Mart saw Dr.Shah at the opening ceremony, they informed Comfort that he had “unknowingly hired the very man” that had designed the dental clinic. The defendants then agreed to send Shah home, on the pretext that he refused to sign a non-disclosure agreement. By the time he got home, Shah said he was “greeted with an email telling him that his services were no longer needed.”

In his litigation, Shah says that Wal-Mart “repeatedly lied… about its plans to open dental offices in Wal-Mart stores across the country. Shah has asked for a trial by jury, and for compensatory and punitive damages.

In response to this lawsuit, a Wal-Mart spokesman told The City Wire that his company “did not misappropriate any information from the plaintiff in this case. Simply put, his (Shah’s) allegations are baseless and misguided. Offering our customers access to services they want, like independent medical, banking and restaurants, enables us to deliver on our commitment to offer one-stop shopping. We will continue to provide products and services that our customers are interested in and this includes leasing space to others when it makes sense.”

Readers are urged to contact Wal-Mart’s Ethics Office for the U.S.A. at 1-800-963-8442 with the following message:

“I think Wal-Mart Ethics should look into Wal-Mart’s ethics in allegedly ‘stealing’ the idea for an in-store dental clinic from the dentist who designed the concept. Not that I would ever entrust my dental care to a company like Wal-Mart — but it concerns me that your company would lie and steal to make a profit off another person’s idea.

If these charges are true — and Wal-Mart should hire an independent investigator to get to the ‘root’ of the problem — then Wal-Mart should publicly apologize to this dentist and offer him a good settlement out of court.”

Ask almost anyone who has sued Wal-Mart over the past half century, and they will tell you that getting justice out of the giant retailer is like pulling teeth. That may be a good sign for a California dentist who claims that Wal-Mart conspired with others to steal his concept for a dental clinic inside of big box stores.

Like this article?

Share on facebook
Share on Facebook
Share on twitter
Share on Twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on Linkdin
Share on pinterest
Share on Pinterest
Al Norman

Al Norman

Al Norman first achieved national attention in October of 1993 when he successfully stopped Wal-Mart from locating in his hometown of Greenfield, Massachusetts. Almost 3 decades later they is still not Wal-Mart in Greenfield. Norman has appeared on 60 Minutes, was featured in three films, wrote 3 books about Wal-Mart, and gained widespread media attention from the Wall Street Journal to Fortune magazine. Al has traveled throughout the U.S., Barbados, Puerto Rico, Ireland, and Japan, helping dozens of local coalitions fight off unwanted sprawl development. 60 Minutes called Al “the guru of the anti-Wal-Mart movement.”

Leave a comment

Find Us

  • 21 Grinnell St, Greenfield, MA
  • (413) 834-4284
  • [email protected]

Helpful Links

  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
Menu
  • Terms
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy

Recent Posts

CHRISTIAN SMALLS, FIRED AMZN WAREHOUSE WORKER, FILES RACE DISCRIMATION LAWSUIT. …

November 16, 2020

DUE TO THE SURGE IN CORONA CASES, WMT IS LIMITING SHOPPERS TO 5 PER 1,000 SF. A…

November 16, 2020

AMAZON RECENTLY ANNOUNCED FREE 1 HOUR GROCERY PICK UP FOR PRIME MEMBER ORDERS &g…

November 15, 2020

AFTER BEING REJECTED BY THE DEERFIELD, MA PLANNING BOARD, DOLLAR GENERAL APPEALS…

November 15, 2020

WILL TRUMP ALLOW ORACLE & WALMART TO INVEST IN TIK TOK? The deadline to ban …

November 14, 2020

AMAZON ACCUSED OF BREAKING ANTITRUST RULES IN EUROPE. “Data of 3rd-party sellers…

November 14, 2020

WALMART PET CARE NOW SELLING PET INSURANCE. My 3 year old mixed breed cat would …

November 13, 2020

WALMART’S GOING TO THE DOGS. 90 M OF ITS CUSTOMERS HAVE DOGS. You’d be Goofy not…

November 13, 2020

WALMART CASHIERS STILL LOOKING FOR A SEAT. They won a $65 M lawsuit in 2019, but…

November 12, 2020

4 DAYS BEFORE THE PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION,THE CO-FOUNDER OF HOME DEPOT SAID: “Pres…

November 12, 2020

Recent Tweets

Al Norman 14 hours ago

WALMART ADMITS IT “MADE A MISTAKE” IN FL. VACCINE ROLLOUT. Several thousand people under age 65 with underlying conditions were given appointments. https://t.co/VPF3CBeezv

Read More
Al Norman 14 hours ago

WITH TRUMP GONE, TIK TOK DOESN’T HAVE TO DO A DEAL WITH WALMART. “The deal was mainly designed to entertain demands from the Trump administration. But Trump is gone, & the raison d’être of the deal is gone with him.” Politics + Biz = Bad BIz. https://t.co/U3chrquEuN

Read More
Al Norman 1 day ago

"No nation can succeed that tolerates violence or the threat of violence as a method of political intimidation, coercion, or control. We all know that. Such conduct must be fiercely opposed and firmly prosecuted.” DJ TRUMP, 10/18. https://t.co/s1dClpyRru

Read More

Ⓒ 2020 - All Rights Are Reserved

Design and Development by Just Peachy Web Design

Download Our Free Guide

Download our Free Guide

Learn How To Stop Big Box Stores And Fulfillment Warehouses In Your Community

The strategies written here were produced by Sprawl-Busters in 2006 at the request of the United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW), mainly for citizen groups that were fighting Walmart. But the tips for fighting unwanted development apply to any project—whether its fighting Dollar General, an Amazon warehouse, or a Home Depot.

Big projects, or small, these BATTLEMART TIPS will help you better understand what you are up against, and how to win your battle.